BROKEN DOLLS

Grieving sisters are hunted by haunted dolls.

Kaye, a sensitive girl from Brooklyn who’s in therapy for arithmomania (a compulsion to count) as well as other anxious symptoms such as intrusive thoughts and catastrophizing, is spending the summer in upstate New York with her family at her recently deceased grandfather’s house. Grief has left her struggling and hardly speaking. At the local Cheese Festival, Kaye and younger sister Holly encounter a strange man who calls himself the Poppet Maker. He engages them with games like cards and a cup and ring, and Holly wins an exquisite doll. The man calls it Holly-doll—and it does look just like Holly, who’s delighted by what the Poppet Maker claims is a coincidence. Kaye feels sure something is wrong. Holly-doll soon guides Holly to unearth an ever-increasing number of creepy dolls that Kaye sees moving on their own—unless it’s her imagination? Unable to turn for help to skeptical adults, like her grieving mom and uncle or her therapist, Dr. Shanti, Kaye confides in her new friend and crush, Joey, a local girl. The dolls’ increasing aggression creates wonderful (and non-gory) scares. Some of the solutions to the mysteries feel a bit spoon-fed (for example, answers revealed through a discovered diary and a villain’s flashback), and other intriguing questions are never answered. But the climax gives young readers a blood-free taste of body horror, and a final stinger keeps the chills alive. The characters largely present white.

Solid scares elevated by psychological richness.