WHERE SHE LIES

DCI Christine Caplan is flummoxed by an investigation into a family even more dysfunctional than her own.

When Caplan’s daughter Emma’s boyfriend announces the couple’s engagement over dinner, her unemployed son Kenny’s response is to ask his prospective brother-in-law for “a loan of ten grand.” A call about a possible fatality at Torsvaig Castle, an hour or so from her cottage on the coast of Scotland, offers Caplan an escape from the awkward conversation, but not before Kenny’s girlfriend, Jade, chimes in with an excoriating critique of Police Scotland. Once at Torsvaig, Caplan finds a scene that’s hard to process. Famous model Koi McQuarrie has lived there with her husband, photographer Gabriel Samphire, and five adult children, who’d been celebrating the recent success of the castle as a wedding venue. After an evening of drink and dancing, Koi retreated to the castle’s ramparts and vanished. Caplan and her team are faced with the classic police triad: fell, jumped, or pushed? Their inquiry is vastly complicated when Koi’s body, after appearing briefly on the rocks below, disappears. The complex dynamics of Koi’s blended family threaten to eclipse the police procedural, as the mental health needs of her grieving brood thwart all attempts to establish a coherent account of what happened that night. Ramsay’s richly detailed descriptions of the physical landscape of Torsvaig and of the private landscape of the McQuarrie-Samphires’ inner lives project a brooding melancholy, but the investigation doesn’t really get into gear until the last third of the book. The police turn out to be not at all as inept as Jade claims, though not for want of trying.

For fans who like their mystery with a major dose of misery.